Ready to Purchase?

A true Lake Expert
As a true lake expert I do more than just sell homes—I live and breathe the lifestyle! Whether we’re talking docks, lifts, the perfect boat setup, or the best spots to drop anchor and relax, I make sure my clients have all the inside scoop to enjoy lake life to the fullest. Need to know where the deepest water is? I got you. Curious about no-wake zones? Let’s chat. Want to test-drive the lake before making a move? Hop aboard! I’m always up for a cruise to dinner, chasing a sunset, or a day on the water surfing, foiling, or barefooting. Lake life is something special, and I’d love to help you find the perfect home so you can start making incredible memories too!
Get your next home
Sold by Sheets
Our Clients:
Buying With
Andy Sheets
When you work with me, you won’t be passed around between multiple agents or team members. You’ll have direct communication with me from start to finish, ensuring a seamless, consistent, and personalized experience.
As a longtime resident of Morse, I have an in-depth understanding of the lake and its property values. I often know about homes before they hit the market and leverage my connections and local insight to help buyers find the perfect match. Living on the lake myself, I truly understand the lifestyle and what makes these properties unique.
With 18+ years in the business and over $300 million in lifetime sales—$125 million of which is on the lake—I have the expertise, market knowledge, and negotiation skills to deliver the best results for my buyers. My deep understanding of the lake market ensures you get the most value, whether buying or selling.
I provide expert guidance every step of the way to ensure a smooth transaction. With my extensive experience in negotiating purchase agreement terms, handling home inspection responses and repairs, and navigating the appraisal process, I’m here to protect your interests and keep things on track. There might be surprises along the way, but you can count on me to help you navigate them with confidence and clarity.
A true lake expert does more than just sell homes—he lives and breathes the lifestyle! Whether we’re talking docks, lifts, the perfect boat setup, or the best spots to drop anchor and relax, I make sure my clients have all the inside scoop to enjoy lake life to the fullest. Need to know where the deepest water is? I got you. Curious about no-wake zones? Let’s chat. Want to test-drive the lake before making a move? Hop aboard! I’m always up for a cruise to dinner, chasing a sunset, or a day on the water surfing, foiling, or barefooting. Lake life is something special, and I’d love to help you find the perfect home so you can start making incredible memories too!
Off the Water?
No Problem
From the lake to the surrounding communities, Andy knows Hamilton County real estate
If you’re thinking about buying a home—lakefront or not—Andy’s the guy you want on your side. Sure, he’s the Morse Lake expert, with $120 million in lake home sales, but he’s also helped buyers with $180 million in homes throughout Noblesville, Cicero, and the rest of Hamilton County. He knows the market, the neighborhoods, and even the homes that haven’t hit the market yet. Whether you’re looking for a dream lake house or the perfect place nearby, Andy’s experience and connections will help you find the right home at the right price. Let’s go find your next home!
